Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support my research and content. Read my full affiliate disclosure here.
Replacing the tires on your 2009–2013 Subaru Forester affects ride comfort, fuel economy, and winter performance more than many owners realize. The right tires improve wet and light-snow grip, reduce road noise, and extend tread life while keeping handling predictable for daily driving and occasional adventures.This guide highlights seven top options shortlisted for the Forester, explaining the criteria used to evaluate them and what matters for each driving condition. Read on to compare factors such as size fitment, tread design, and longevity to find the best match for your driving style and local weather.
Looking for other parts? See all Subaru Forester parts & accessories.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Best Overall The best all-around choice for most situations | Yokohama Avid Ascend GT 215/60R16 95H Passenger Tire |  |
| Best Quality Built to a higher standard if you want something more solid | MICHELIN Primacy MXV4 215/55R17 94V Passenger Touring All-Season Tire |  |
| Best Value The sweet spot between price and what you get | Milestar MS932 Sport All-Season Performance Tire 215/60R16 95H |  |
| Best Budget The cheapest option that still gets the job done reliably | Starfire Solarus AS All-Season Tire 215/55R17 94V |  |
| Highest Rated A top-rated pick with lots of positive feedback | Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail 225/60R17 All-Terrain Tire |  |
| Most Popular A crowd favorite that many people choose with confidence | Starfire Solarus AS All-Season Tire 215/60R16 95V | |
| Best Seller A high-volume bestseller chosen again and again | Fullway HP108 215/55R17 High-Performance Passenger Tire |  |
1. Yokohama Avid Ascend GT 215/60R16 95H Passenger Tire
| Rim Size | 16 Inches |
|---|---|
| Load Index | 95.0 |
| Speed Rating | H |
| Tread Type | Asymmetrical |
| Seasons | Summer |
The Yokohama Avid Ascend GT is a grand touring all-season tire aimed at drivers who want a balanced mix of comfort, traction, and longevity. It uses a silica-rich triblend compound and asymmetric tread to improve wet grip and light winter performance while multi-pitch tread and adaptive outer shoulder blocks reduce road noise for a quiet highway ride. Triple 3D sipes and an ultra-square contact patch help extend tread life and maintain even wear, and Yokohama backs the design with a long limited treadwear warranty. In practice this tire performs well on wet roads and offers stable, predictable handling in everyday driving; it is not a performance summer tire but provides better year-round usability than a dedicated summer tire. Buyers should note the 65,000-mile warranty is conditional and real-world wear will depend on alignment and rotation habits; also this is a touring tire so drivers seeking maximum sporty grip or track capability should look elsewhere.
Best for: Drivers seeking a quiet, long-lasting touring tire that balances wet, dry, and light winter performance for daily driving on a Subaru Forester from 2009 to 2013.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who prioritize maximum dry performance, aggressive cornering, or track-focused grip should consider a high-performance summer tire instead.
- All-season silica-rich compound for improved wet and light winter traction
- Asymmetric tread and multi-pitch design reduce road noise for a quiet ride
- Features 3D sipes and an ultra-square contact patch to promote even wear and longer tread life
- Designed for touring comfort rather than aggressive sporty handling or track use
Verdict: A durable, quiet grand touring tire that gives 2009–2013 Forester drivers balanced year-round traction and long tread life.
2. MICHELIN Primacy MXV4 215/55R17 94V Passenger Touring All-Season Tire
| Rim Size | 17 inches |
|---|---|
| Load Index | 94 |
| Speed Rating | V |
| Seasons | Year Round |
The MICHELIN Primacy MXV4 is a passenger touring all-season tire intended to deliver a quiet, comfortable driving experience while providing predictable year-round grip. It uses Comfort Control Technology and a reinforced tread compound with dense siping to improve wet traction, while larger circumferential and lateral grooves help channel water and resist hydroplaning. MaxTouch construction is aimed at even wear and stable handling during everyday driving. This tire is typically used as a replacement for street-driven compact and midsize cars fitted with 17-inch wheels, providing a smoother ride and reduced road noise compared with performance summer tires. Expect good longevity and consistent braking in wet and dry conditions, but do not expect the same cornering bite or high-temperature endurance as dedicated performance or ultra-high-performance tires. The Primacy MXV4 is best for drivers who prioritize comfort, low noise and long tread life over aggressive handling or track driving capability.
Best for: Drivers who prioritize a quiet, comfortable daily driving experience and long tread life for street and highway use on a 2009–2013 Subaru Forester.
Less Ideal for: Drivers seeking maximum cornering grip, track performance, or aggressive high-speed handling should consider a dedicated performance tire instead.
- Comfort Control Technology reduces road noise and delivers a smoother ride
- Dense siping and reinforced tread compound improve wet-weather traction
- MaxTouch construction promotes even wear for longer tread life
- Large circumferential and lateral grooves enhance water evacuation to resist hydroplaning
- Designed for touring comfort so lateral grip and high-speed cornering are below ultra-high-performance tires
Verdict: Choose the Primacy MXV4 if you want a quiet, comfortable all-season replacement that emphasizes wet traction and long wear for daily driving on a 2009–2013 Forester.
3. Milestar MS932 Sport All-Season Performance Tire 215/60R16 95H
| Seasons | Year Round |
|---|---|
| Rim Size | 16 Inches |
| Load Index | 95.0 |
| Speed Rating | H |
| Load Capacity | 1521 Pounds |
The Milestar MS932 Sport is an all-season performance touring tire that aims to deliver confident wet-weather grip, composed handling, and a comfortable, quiet ride. For a 2009–2013 Subaru Forester with 215/60R16 fitment, it installs and performs like a typical highway-performance tire: the silica-enhanced tread compound improves wet traction and the non-directional tread pattern helps even wear and predictable steering response. Milestar backs the design with a 50,000-mile limited treadwear warranty, which speaks to longevity for drivers who prioritize cost per mile. Expect a smooth highway ride and stable cornering at everyday speeds, though this is not an ultra-high-performance tire for spirited track driving. Load index 95 and H speed rating suit typical Forester driving but limit high-speed capability compared with V-rated sport tires. Overall, the MS932 is a value-oriented choice that balances comfort, all-season utility, and advertised treadlife for an unmodified Forester used for commuting and light touring.
Best for: Buyers seeking a cost-conscious, long-lasting all-season tire for daily driving and light touring who prioritize wet-weather confidence and a comfortable ride for their Forester.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who demand extreme high-speed handling, track performance, or specialized winter capability should consider dedicated performance or winter tires instead.
- All-season silica tread compound improves wet traction and helps even treadwear.
- 50,000-mile limited treadwear warranty for long-term value.
- Non-directional tread offers predictable handling and easy rotation patterns.
- Designed for a quiet, comfortable highway ride suitable for daily driving.
- Not aimed at aggressive or track driving so lateral grip at high speeds is limited.
- Available speed ratings top out at H in this size which is lower than some sport tire alternatives.
Verdict: If you want an affordable, long-wearing all-season tire that improves wet traction and comfort on a 2009–2013 Subaru Forester, the MS932 Sport is a practical choice.
4. Starfire Solarus AS All-Season Tire 215/55R17 94V
| Size | 215/55R17 94V |
|---|---|
| Tread Type | Symmetrical |
| Construction Type | Radial |
| Load Capacity | 1477 Pounds |
| UTQG | 520-A-A |
The Starfire Solarus AS is an all-season touring tire aimed at drivers who want a low-cost, long-wearing replacement for everyday use. It uses a re-engineered tread compound and a solid center rib to deliver predictable handling and a smooth highway ride, while shoulder control technology with deep slots and biting edges improves grip in wet conditions and light snow. Variable pitch tread elements help keep road noise down, making it a comfortable choice for commuting and long trips. The tire carries a 50,000-mile warranty and a high UTQG rating that points to strong tread life for the price. As an inexpensive option from a Cooper-manufactured lineup, it provides sensible performance for city and highway driving but will not match premium tires in extreme wet braking, heavy snow, or spirited handling situations. Buyers should expect competent, economical all-season performance rather than high-performance grip or dedicated winter capability.
Best for: Drivers who prioritize low cost and long mileage for everyday commuting and highway use on a 2009–2013 Subaru Forester and want a quiet, dependable all-season tire.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need superior wet braking, heavy snow performance, or sporty handling should consider higher-tier all-season or dedicated winter tires instead.
- Long tread life backed by a 50,000-mile warranty and a high UTQG rating
- Re-engineered compound and shoulder control technology improve wet traction and stability
- Solid center rib and variable pitch tread reduce road noise for a comfortable highway ride
- Not designed for severe winter conditions or aggressive performance driving
Verdict: A practical, budget-friendly all-season touring tire that delivers long mileage and quiet, dependable everyday performance for Forester owners.
5. Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail 225/60R17 All-Terrain Tire
| Size | 225/60R17 |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 1709 Pounds |
| Tread Depth | 11 32nds |
| Construction Type | Radial |
| UTQG | 680AA |
The Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail is an all-terrain radial tire built for CUVs and smaller SUVs, offering a balance between rugged off-road capability and dependable on-road manners. It uses a crossover-specific construction and a silica-based compound to resist uneven wear and extend tread life, while Falken's 3D Canyon Sipe Technology and deep tread give strong bite in wet and snowy conditions. The tire's reinforced upper sidewall and two-ply polyester construction improve resistance to punctures from rocks and trail debris, making it suited for light off-road routes and rough gravel. Practical benefits include a manufacturer-backed 65,000-mile limited tread life and Three Peak Mountain Snowflake winter certification for confidence in snow. Limitations are that it is intended for crossovers and smaller SUVs rather than heavy trucks, so users expecting extreme off-road load capacity or a smooth highway-only touring ride may notice firmer road noise and a stiffer feel compared with highway-specific touring tires.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize dependable, long-lasting traction for mixed on/off-road use and want a tire that handles winter conditions without frequent replacement.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who primarily want the quietest, most comfortable highway-focused tire or need tires rated for heavy truck loads and extreme off-road abuse.
- Crossover-focused construction for improved handling and stability on CUVs and small SUVs
- Durable 2-ply polyester and rugged upper sidewall for better resistance to off-road damage
- 3D Canyon Sipe Technology and deep tread deliver strong wet and winter traction
- Manufacturer-backed 65,000 mile limited tread life for long-term value
- Construction favors durability over plush, quiet highway comfort which can result in firmer ride and more road noise
Verdict: Choose this tire if you want a durable, crossover-tuned all-terrain that delivers long tread life and confident wet and winter traction for a Forester-class vehicle.
6. Starfire Solarus AS All-Season Tire 215/60R16 95V
| Rim Size | 16 Inches |
|---|---|
| Load Index | 95.0 |
| Speed Rating | V |
| Tread Type | Symmetrical |
| Seasons | Year Round |
The Starfire Solarus AS is an all-season touring tire built for everyday driving and highway miles. Its symmetrical tread with a solid center rib and variable pitch design aims to reduce road noise while providing stable handling. Deep lateral shoulder grooves and carefully placed sipes improve wet traction and biting edges for occasional winter conditions, and the re-engineered tread compound supports consistent grip in wet and dry situations. Fitment here is the 215/60R16 95V size, which matches many mid-size crossovers and compact SUVs. Practical benefits include a smooth, controlled ride and a claimed 50,000 mile treadwear warranty from the manufacturer. Limitations to consider are that this is a budget brand produced under Cooper and it may not match premium touring tires for long-term wear consistency or extreme winter performance; very heavy loads or aggressive driving will reveal its design limits. For routine commuting and mixed weather driving, it offers a sensible balance of comfort and traction for cost-conscious buyers.
Best for: Buyers seeking a low-cost, reliable all-season touring tire for daily driving and highway commuting who prioritize quiet ride quality and proven customer feedback.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need dedicated snow or ice performance, frequent heavy-load towing, or aggressive handling characteristics should choose a specialty or premium tire instead.
- All-season tread compound for year-round wet and dry traction
- Symmetrical tread with variable pitch reduces highway noise
- Deep shoulder grooves and sipes enhance wet grip and light snow performance
- Manufacturer lists a 50,000 mile treadwear warranty
- Not optimized for severe winter or high-performance driving compared with premium brands
- Budget positioning may mean shorter long-term wear consistency under heavy use
Verdict: A practical, budget-friendly all-season touring tire that delivers quiet, stable everyday performance for cost-conscious drivers.
7. Fullway HP108 215/55R17 High-Performance Passenger Tire
| Size | 215/55R17 |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 1653 Pounds |
| Load Range | XL |
| Construction Type | Radial |
| UTQG | 380-A-A |
The Fullway HP108 is a summer high-performance passenger tire aimed at drivers who want sporty handling without paying premium brand prices. Its asymmetrical tread and deep center grooves are designed to deliver confident grip and directional stability at higher speeds, making it suitable for everyday highway driving and spirited backroad runs. The XL load range and reinforced 4-ply rating add margin for heavier loads or vehicles with roof cargo. You can expect reasonable tread life for a performance tire thanks to a UTQG of 380-A-A, and the radial construction provides predictable steering response. Limitations include its summer-performance focus rather than true all-season traction in cold or snowy conditions and that ride refinement and noise may not match more expensive, name-brand competitors. Fitment is specific to the 215/55R17 size, so buyers should confirm this size matches their vehicle before ordering.
Best for: A risk-conscious driver looking for a cost-effective upgrade to sharper handling on paved roads who prioritizes predictable performance and load capacity over premium-brand refinement.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need reliable year-round traction in winter conditions or who prioritize the quietest, most comfortable ride from a premium tire.
- Asymmetrical tread and deep center grooves improve high-speed stability and cornering response.
- XL 4-ply rating gives added load capacity for heavier loads or roof cargo.
- High UTQG rating suggests competitive tread life for a performance-oriented tire.
- Radial construction delivers predictable steering feel for everyday driving.
- Designed as a summer/performance tire so traction is limited in cold weather and snow.
- May not match premium-brand tires for noise control and ride refinement.
Verdict: If you want sharper highway and sporty handling on a 215/55R17-equipped vehicle without a premium price, the Fullway HP108 delivers solid performance and load capacity for the money.
Choosing the Right 2009-2013 Subaru Forester Tires: Key Factors to Consider
Correct Tire Size and Load Rating
Tire size and load rating determine whether a tire will fit your Forester without rubbing or changing speedometer readings. Using the size specified in your owner manual or the placard on the driver door ensures proper clearance for the wheel wells and suspension travel.
The load rating matters because an under-rated tire can overheat or wear prematurely when carrying passengers and cargo. Always match or exceed the original load index to maintain braking balance and steering response, and check the speed rating to preserve handling characteristics at highway speeds.
Wet Traction and Hydroplaning Resistance
Rain is a common hazard, and the Forester's higher ride height makes maintaining contact patch control essential. Look for tread compounds and siping patterns designed to evacuate water quickly; these features reduce stopping distances on wet pavement and lower the risk of hydroplaning.
Tread design such as circumferential grooves and lateral channels improves water dispersion. Tires with proven wet-grip ratings or positive user feedback for rainy conditions will make wet-weather driving safer and more predictable.
Snow Performance and Traction in Light Winter Conditions
Many Forester owners encounter snow or slush during winter months, so tires that offer capable light-snow traction are valuable. While full winter tires are necessary for heavy or icy conditions, many all-season and all-weather designs provide improved siping and rubber compounds that remain pliable at lower temperatures.
Consider the tire's winter rating or user reports about snow braking and cornering. A tire that grips well in slush and packed snow will keep your Forester more controllable in typical northern winter scenarios.
Tread Life and Wear Patterns
Tread life affects how often you replace tires and the vehicle's long-term running cost. Look for tires with robust tread compounds and even wear patterns; asymmetric designs often distribute load more evenly across the contact patch.
Treadwear ratings and warranty lengths offer a baseline expectation, but real-world longevity depends on alignment, inflation, and driving habits. Choosing a tire with predictable wear helps avoid uneven replacement intervals or early tread failure.
Noise, Comfort, and Ride Quality
The Forester is often used for commuting and family trips, so cabin noise and ride comfort matter. Tires with optimized tread blocks and noise-reducing patterns provide a quieter ride, while sidewall construction influences how the tire absorbs bumps.
If you prioritize a plush ride, favor touring-oriented all-season designs. If you need firmer response for spirited driving, a performance-oriented compound can improve steering feel but may increase road noise and sacrifice some comfort.
Fuel Efficiency and Rolling Resistance
Rolling resistance impacts fuel economy and is influenced by rubber compound and tire construction. Lower rolling resistance tires can contribute to modest fuel savings over thousands of miles.
For Forester owners who drive long distances frequently, choosing tires with reduced rolling resistance will lower operating costs. Balance this with traction needs, as the most fuel-efficient tires may sacrifice some wet or winter grip.
Understanding OEM Fitment and Optional Wheel Sizes
The 2009 13 Forester can be fitted with a range of wheel diameters and tire profiles depending on trim and wheel upgrades. Before you buy, confirm the factory-recommended sizes from your owner manual or the placard in the driver door area. If you run aftermarket wheels, verify offset and backspacing to prevent rubbing during full-lock turns or when the suspension compresses.
- Check the tire size stamped on the sidewall of existing tires.
- Confirm the vehicle placard size and recommended cold inflation pressures.
- When changing wheel diameter, recalculate overall tire diameter to keep speedometer accuracy.
Seasonal Strategies: All-Season Vs Dedicated Winter Tires
For many Forester owners, a well-chosen all-season tire provides a year-round balance of wet and light-snow performance. However, if you regularly face heavy snow or ice, dedicated winter tires with softer rubber and aggressive siping offer superior traction and braking.Switching between sets seasonally preserves tread life and optimizes performance. If you use one set year-round, prioritize a tire designed for predictable behavior across spring-to-fall temperatures while still offering credible light-winter capability.
- All-season: good for a mix of conditions and convenience.
- Winter tires: better braking and traction on snow and ice.
Interpreting Treadwear Ratings and Manufacturer Warranties
Treadwear grades and mileage warranties provide a comparative baseline but are not guarantees. A higher treadwear rating can mean longer life under similar driving conditions, but actual mileage depends on inflation, alignment, and driving style.Consider the warranty length alongside the expected driving you do. Manufacturers sometimes prorate warranties, so understand how adjustments are handled and what conditions can void coverage.
- Treadwear numbers are comparative, not absolute.
- Warranties often require proof of maintenance for claims.
Installation: Balancing and Alignment Considerations
Proper installation matters as much as the tire choice. After mounting, tires should be balanced to prevent vibration at highway speeds. A correct alignment ensures even wear and predictable handling, especially on a Forester where toe and camber affect steering feel.Verify the shop sets cold inflation pressures to the placard values and rechecks torque after the first 50 to 100 miles.
- Balance to eliminate steering-wheel vibration.
- Alignment promotes even tread wear and precise handling.
- Re-torque lug nuts after initial driving miles.
Maintaining Tires: Inflation, Rotation, and Tread Inspection
Regular maintenance extends tread life and preserves safety. Check tire pressures monthly and before long trips, rotating the tires at recommended intervals to even out wear. Inspect tread depth and look for signs of abnormal wear patterns that could indicate alignment or suspension issues.Pay attention to sidewall damage and embedded objects that can compromise integrity. Use a tread depth gauge to confirm safe remaining life and replace tires when they reach minimum legal or manufacturer-recommended depths.
- Rotate tires per the owner manual schedule.
- Use a gauge to monitor tread depth regularly.
- Inspect for cuts, bulges, and uneven wear.
Still looking for the perfect fit?
Select your Subaru Forester configuration to see the most relevant Tires recommendations
How We Chose the Best 2009-2013 Subaru Forester Tires
We focused on criteria that matter specifically to owners of 2009–2013 Subaru Forester models and the typical driving those vehicles see. First, we prioritized fitment and load index compatibility for the Forester wheel and suspension setups in the 2009 13 model years to ensure safe handling and correct speed ratings. Second, we evaluated wet- and snow-traction performance, using manufacturer wet-grip and winter ratings as proxies for real-world control in rain and light snow. Third, we looked at tread life indicators and manufacturer wear warranties to assess long-term value and replacement frequency.Other important filters included ride comfort and noise levels, because many Forester owners use these vehicles for daily commuting and longer trips; fuel efficiency impact, measured via rolling resistance specs; and directional or asymmetric tread designs that influence braking and cornering behavior. We excluded any tires lacking clear fitment information for the 2009 13 Forester, as well as options with speed or load ratings below OEM recommendations. Ultimately, the selections balance safety, longevity, and all-season usability for this specific vehicle.
Our full evaluation process is outlined in our review methodology.
FAQ
What tire size should I use on my 2009 13 Subaru Forester?
Use the size listed on the driver door placard or in the owner manual for your specific model and trim. If you change wheel diameter, ensure the overall tire diameter stays close to factory to avoid speedometer and clearance issues.
Are all-season tires adequate for northern winters in a Forester?
All-season tires offer reasonable performance for light snow and slush, but in areas with frequent heavy snow or ice, dedicated winter tires deliver noticeably better traction and shorter stopping distances.
How often should I replace tires on a Forester?
Replacement frequency depends on mileage, driving habits, and maintenance. Many tires last between 30,000 and 70,000 miles; check tread depth and watch for uneven wear. If tread depth approaches the legal minimum or traction declines, replace them.
Will switching to larger wheels affect ride quality?
Larger wheels with lower-profile tires can sharpen steering response but usually increase road noise and reduce ride cushioning. Make sure the new tire profile still clears the suspension and does not alter the overall rolling diameter significantly.
How can I tell when treads are worn out?
Measure tread depth with a gauge and look for treadwear indicators molded into the grooves. If depth reaches the legal limit or those indicators are flush with the tread, it is time to replace the tire.
Do I need my wheels balanced after buying new tires?
Yes. Proper balancing eliminates vibration and prevents premature wear. Have the tires balanced at installation and rechecked if vibration occurs after a few hundred miles.
Final Verdict
For the 2009 13 Subaru Forester, prioritize correct size and load rating, plus wet-traction and reliable tread life when choosing tires. Balance your needs between comfortable daily driving and the level of winter performance required in your area. Remember that maintenance such as regular inflation checks, rotations, and alignments plays a major role in how long any tire will perform.Use the factors outlined here to weigh tradeoffs: pick a touring all-season for quiet, long-wearing service; choose a more aggressive all-weather or dedicated winter tire if you need improved snow grip. Focus on fitment and ratings first, then dial in tread pattern and compound to match your local roads and driving habits to make a confident selection.
Explore More:
- Check out all Subaru Forester parts & accessories
- Explore Tires Maintenance & Repair Guides
- Explore Wheels & Tires
- Browse all Auto Parts
