Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support my research and content. Read my full affiliate disclaimer here.
If you drive a Subaru Forester and want more capability off the beaten path, choosing the right all terrain tires matters for safety and performance. The wrong tire can reduce traction on wet roads, increase road noise, or wear prematurely under regular driving conditions. This guide shortlists the best options for Forester owners, focusing on real-world criteria like wet traction, tread life, ride comfort, and load capacity. Below you will find our top picks that passed those filters and a clear explanation of how we evaluated them.
Looking for other parts? See all Subaru Forester parts & accessories.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Best Reviewed A top-rated pick with lots of positive feedback | Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail All-Terrain Tire (225/65R17) |  |
| Most Popular A crowd favorite that many people choose with confidence | Atturo Trail Blade A/T All-Terrain Tire (265/70R17) |  |
| Best Quality Built to a higher standard if you want something more solid | Cooper Evolution M/T All-Terrain Tire LT265/70R17 |  |
| Best Budget The cheapest option that still gets the job done reliably | Travelstar Ecopath A/T All-Terrain Tire 265/70R17 (Tire Only) |  |
| Most Sold A high-volume bestseller chosen again and again | Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT All-Terrain 265/70R17 Tire |  |
| Best Value for Money The sweet spot between price and what you get | Multi-Mile Wild Country XTX AT4S All-Terrain Tire, 265/70R17 |  |
| Best Overall The best all-around choice for most situations | Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus 265/70R17 115T Tire |  |
1. Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail All-Terrain Tire (225/65R17)
| Size | 225/65R17 |
|---|---|
| Tread Depth | 11 32nds |
| Load Capacity | 1874 Pounds |
| Construction Type | Radial |
| UTQG | 680AA |
The Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail is built as a crossover-focused all-terrain tire that brings tougher off-road traction to a vehicle like the Subaru Forester while maintaining comfortable on-road manners. It is typically used as a direct replacement on Foresters that see a mix of gravel, mud, snow, and daily highway driving. Notable features include a crossover-specific construction for better stability on taller unibody vehicles, a rugged upper sidewall to resist punctures, and 3D Canyon Sipe Technology that maintains bite for wet and snowy traction as the tread wears. Practical benefits for a reliability-minded Forester owner are strong winter capability thanks to Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification, longer tread life backed by a 65,000-mile limited tread-life claim, and reduced risk of sidewall damage off-road. Limitations are modest: the more aggressive tread can slightly increase rolling resistance compared with touring tires, which may reduce fuel economy and blunt acceleration, and drivers who need maximal ice performance or extreme off-road mud capability may prefer more specialized winter or mud-terrain tires.
Best for: Reliability-focused Forester owners who prioritize durable, predictable traction year-round and want a tire that tolerates light off-road use without sacrificing daily driving comfort.
Less Ideal for: Drivers seeking maximum ice-specific performance, competitive fuel economy, or extreme mud-terrain capability should consider a dedicated winter tire, low-rolling-resistance touring tire, or a mud-terrain option instead.
- Crossover-specific construction improves handling and stability on taller unibody vehicles
- Rugged upper sidewall and 2-ply polyester construction increase resistance to off-road punctures
- 3D Canyon Sipe Technology preserves wet and snow traction as tread wears
- Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification for winter use
- Manufacturer-backed 65,000 mile limited tread-life for longer service life
- Aggressive all-terrain tread can raise rolling resistance and slightly reduce fuel economy
- Not optimized for pure ice performance or extreme deep-mud conditions
Verdict A durable, crossover-tuned all-terrain tire that gives Subaru Forester owners reliable year-round traction and off-road resilience while trading a bit of fuel efficiency for toughness.
2. Atturo Trail Blade A/T All-Terrain Tire (265/70R17)
| Size | 265/70R17 |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 2680 Pounds |
| Tread Depth | 13 32nds |
| Maximum Pressure | 44 PSI |
| Construction Type | Radial |
The Atturo Trail Blade A/T is an all-terrain tire aimed at drivers who need dependable performance on pavement and light off-road surfaces. It uses wave-shaped siping and four wide lateral channels to evacuate water and snow, which helps reduce hydroplaning and improves winter grip thanks to its 3-peak mountain snowflake certification. A linked center rib promotes stable steering and precise handling on highways, while the tread pattern and 50,000-mile treadwear warranty promise longer life for daily driving. In real-world use the tire delivers a quiet, composed ride for street-focused trucks and SUVs and strong traction in snow and wet conditions. Limitations include occasional reports of variability in quality and at least one serious failure in a user review, so inspection at mounting and routine monitoring are advisable. Buyers should also confirm the 265/70R17 size fits their Forester and expect the typical compromises of an all-terrain tire compared with a dedicated mud or highway tire.
Best for: Convenience-driven buyers who prioritize dependable, year-round traction and low-hassle performance for daily driving and occasional light off-road trips.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who regularly tackle extreme off-road terrain or need the deepest mud or rock traction should choose a more specialized off-road tire.
- 3PMS snow certification for reliable winter traction
- Wave-shaped sipes and wide channels that help evacuate water and slush to reduce hydroplaning risk
- Linked center rib for stable, responsive handling on pavement
- 50,000-mile treadwear warranty for extended tread life
- A small number of user reports cite quality or durability failures
- Not as aggressive off-road as a dedicated mud-terrain tire
Verdict A balanced, year-round all-terrain tire that emphasizes snow and wet performance with a long treadwear backing, suited for drivers who want low-maintenance, reliable traction.
3. Cooper Evolution M/T All-Terrain Tire LT265/70R17
| Size | LT265/70R17 121/118Q |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 3195 Pounds |
| Tread Depth | 18.5 32nds |
| Maximum Pressure | 80 PSI |
| Construction Type | Radial |
The Cooper Evolution M/T is a mud-terrain–styled all-terrain tire built to bite into mud, sand, and loose surfaces while resisting stone damage on rough trails. In use it delivers aggressive grip off-road thanks to large Earth Diggers blocks and wide trenches that help evacuate mud, and the tread is pre-drillable for studs to improve low-speed winter traction. Stone Barriers and deep tread depth improve durability when running on rocky routes, and buyers report the tire is quieter and more composed on pavement than many M/Ts, though some road noise and reduced fuel economy are expected. It comes in a 265/70R17 LT fitment with an E load rating for heavier loads. Important limitations for a Forester-focused buyer are size and suspension fitment: the LT265/70R17 is notably taller and wider than stock Forester tire sizes and may require lift, trimming, or different wheel offsets to clear fenders, and the heavier construction can reduce mpg and ride refinement on long highway drives.
Best for: Performance-oriented buyers who prioritize off-road traction and durability and are willing to modify or accept compromises for a more aggressive tire on a Forester.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who want factory-like ride comfort, maximum fuel economy, or a direct bolt-on replacement that fits a stock Forester without suspension or wheel changes.
- Aggressive tread with Earth Diggers and Mud Slingers for strong off-road mud and loose surface traction
- Studdable design for improved winter traction when needed
- Stone Barriers and deep tread increase resistance to rock damage and debris
- Generally quieter and more composed on pavement than typical mud-terrain tires
- LT 265/70R17 size and E load construction are heavier and wider than typical Forester tires and can reduce fuel economy
- May require suspension lift, wheel spacing changes, or fender clearance work to fit a Subaru Forester
Verdict Buy this if you want aggressive, durable off-road traction and studdable winter capability and are prepared to adjust fitment and accept heavier road manners on a Forester.
4. Travelstar Ecopath A/T All-Terrain Tire 265/70R17 (Tire Only)
| Size | 265/70R17-115T |
|---|---|
| Tread Type | All-Terrain |
| Tread Depth | 12.6 32nds |
| Maximum Pressure | 44 PSI |
| UTQG | 520-A-B |
The Travelstar Ecopath A/T is an all-terrain radial designed to give SUVs and light trucks competent off-road traction while remaining comfortable on pavement. It features a deep tread pattern and a 12.6/32 tread depth that helps bite in loose surfaces and light snow, and a 520-A-B UTQG rating indicating decent wear for the price. Typical use is mixed driving where occasional dirt roads, gravel and winter roads meet daily highway miles. Buyers will appreciate the reasonably quiet highway manners reported by users and the substantial load rating for heavier Forester configurations. Practical benefits include a three-year road hazard warranty and an advertised long tread life for a budget tire. Limitations are typical of value all-terrain tires: they can throw rocks, may wear faster than premium A/Ts in severe conditions, and some owners report minor high-speed vibration that may require balancing or alignment to correct.
Best for: Budget-conscious owners seeking an affordable all-terrain look and capable mixed-surface performance for everyday driving and occasional dirt or snowy roads.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who prioritize maximum tread life, the quietest highway noise levels, or extreme off-road rock-crawling performance should consider higher-tier all-terrain or dedicated off-road tires instead.
- Strong off-road traction from a deep all-terrain tread pattern suitable for gravel and light trails
- Relatively quiet and comfortable on highway drives compared with aggressive A/T designs
- High load capacity and a UTQG 520-A-B rating that suggests reasonable wear for a budget tire
- Includes a three-year road hazard warranty for added peace of mind
- May kick up and throw rocks more than premium designs
- Tire wear and longevity can be shorter than higher-end all-terrain tires under heavy use
- Some reports of vibration at higher speeds requiring rebalancing or alignment
Verdict A wallet-friendly all-terrain tire that gives Subaru Forester owners decent off-road capability and a quiet highway ride for everyday mixed-use driving.
5. Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT All-Terrain 265/70R17 Tire
| Size | 265/70R17 |
|---|---|
| Tread Depth | 12 32nds |
| Maximum Pressure | 51 Pound per Square Inch |
| Construction Type | Radial |
| UTQG | 580-B-B |
The Goodyear Wrangler Workhorse AT is an all-terrain radial tire built to deliver dependable traction on pavement and light off-road surfaces. It is typically used on trucks and SUVs to handle mixed conditions where drivers want a balance of on-road comfort and capability on gravel or dirt access roads. Notable features include a 50,000-mile treadwear limited warranty and a symmetrical tread that aims for steady wear and predictable handling. In practical terms this tire gives a confidence-inspiring ride for everyday driving while offering extra bite when you need to pull onto unpaved surfaces, and the high maximum pressure supports carrying heavier loads. Limitations include its 265/70R17 sizing, which must match the vehicle's wheel and clearance, and the all-terrain design compromises ultimate on-road quietness and fuel economy compared with a highway tire. For a risk-averse buyer wanting factory-quality replacement performance and long tread life, it is a straightforward, conservative choice for mixed driving conditions on compatible vehicles.
Best for: A cautious, risk-averse buyer who prioritizes proven reliability and long tread life for mixed on-road and light off-road use in everyday ownership.
Less Ideal for: Drivers seeking the quietest, most fuel-efficient highway tire or those who need aggressive off-road mud-terrain capability should consider other specialized tires.
- 50,000-mile treadwear limited warranty for long expected life
- Symmetrical all-terrain tread for predictable handling on and off road
- Designed by a major tire manufacturer, offering factory-quality replacement fit and support
- Tire size must match vehicle wheel and clearance, limiting fitment options
- All-terrain tread is louder and less fuel-efficient than a highway-specific tire
Verdict A conservative, long-wearing all-terrain tire that suits risk-averse buyers who want reliable mixed-surface performance if the 265/70R17 size fits their Forester.
6. Multi-Mile Wild Country XTX AT4S All-Terrain Tire, 265/70R17
| Size | 265/70R17 |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 2679 Pounds |
| Tread Depth | 13 32nds |
| Maximum Pressure | 44 PSI |
| Construction Type | Radial |
The Multi-Mile Wild Country XTX AT4S is an all-terrain, all-season radial tire aimed at drivers who need capable traction across pavement, dirt and light trails. It is typically used as a replacement tire for vehicles that see mixed driving — daily commuting, weekend trail runs and occasional snow. The aggressive, non-directional tread with deep grooves promotes grip in wet and loose surfaces while self-cleaning channels help prevent mud buildup off-road. Reviewers report a quiet, comfortable ride for an aggressive tread and strong initial traction. Practical benefits include a high UTQG rating and a reinforced construction that supports heavier loads for towing or carrying gear. Limitations to consider are variable long-term durability reports and at least one account of premature failure, so buyers who keep the tire under heavy commercial use should monitor wear patterns closely. Tire-specific fitment and professional mounting and balancing are recommended to preserve ride quality and handling.
Best for: Practical optimizers who want maximum capability per dollar and plan to mix daily driving with occasional off-road or snowy trips.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need guaranteed long-term commercial durability or those wanting a premium-brand warranty and proven longevity should consider higher-end alternatives.
- Aggressive all-terrain tread for improved grip on dirt, mud and snow
- Self-cleaning grooves and deep siping that help maintain traction off-road
- Reportedly quiet and comfortable on-road for its tread type
- Mixed reports on long-term durability with isolated instances of rapid failure
- Limited brand track record compared with premium tire makers
Verdict A budget-friendly all-terrain tire that delivers strong initial traction and quiet on-road manners, but watch for mixed long-term durability reports.
7. Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus 265/70R17 115T Tire
| Size | 265/70R17 115T |
|---|---|
| Tread Depth | 12 32nds |
| Maximum Pressure | 44 PSI |
| Load Capacity | 2679 Pounds |
| UTQG | 640AB |
The Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus is built to balance on-road comfort with off-road capability. It uses an aggressive, symmetrical tread pattern and a robust carcass to shed mud, slush, and water while providing grip on rocks, dirt, and snow. For a Subaru Forester, these tires deliver quieter highway manners than many off-road-focused tires and improved traction in wet and winter conditions thanks to the tread spacing and compound. Installation is standard for vehicle-specific fitments and the tire is marketed as universal fit within its size, so it will mount and perform like other factory-quality replacements when the Forester accepts 265/70R17. Practical benefits include confident braking and predictable handling across mixed surfaces and a tread designed to resist damage on rough trails. Reported downsides include occasional manufacturing-date and cosmetic inconsistencies and some owners noting faster-than-expected wear or sidewall thinness under extreme off-road abuse, so drivers who push heavy off-road loads should monitor wear closely.
Best for: A balanced all-round buyer who wants one tire that handles daily highway driving, occasional trails, and winter roads without sacrificing comfort or predictable handling.
Less Ideal for: Not the best choice for drivers who regularly do heavy rock-crawling, carry extreme loads off-road, or want extended commercial-grade tread life under intensive use.
- Aggressive tread pattern that evacuates water, mud, and slush for improved traction
- Quieter, smoother highway ride than many all-terrain tires, making daily driving comfortable
- Robust carcass and all-season compound designed to handle mixed off-road surfaces including snow and rocks
- Sidewalls are reported thinner than some competitors, which may limit heavy-duty off-road abuse resistance
- Some buyers received older manufacture dates or missing cosmetic details compared with images
- A few reports of accelerated tread wear on high-mileage drivers
Verdict A versatile all-terrain tire that gives Subaru Forester drivers a comfortable highway ride and reliable mixed-surface traction, but monitor wear and sidewall demands if you do heavy off-road work.
Choosing the Right Subaru Forester All Terrain Tires: Key Factors to Consider
Tread Compound and Wet Traction
Tread compound directly influences how a tire grips wet and slippery surfaces. Softer compounds often provide better bite on cold or wet pavement, which reduces stopping distances and improves cornering confidence. However, softer rubber can wear faster in abrasive conditions, so look for compounds formulated to balance grip and longevity.
Manufacturers sometimes add silica or other polymers to enhance wet traction without sacrificing wear. For everyday Forester driving, prioritize a compound that maintains traction in rain and light mud while still offering reasonable tread life.
Tread Pattern and Off-Road Versatility
The tread pattern determines how well a tire evacuates water, sheds mud, and maintains contact on uneven surfaces. All terrain designs usually feature shoulder blocks and interlocking tread elements to provide traction on dirt and gravel while still tracking smoothly on pavement. More aggressive patterns improve off-road purchase but can increase road noise and rolling resistance.
Consider how often you will encounter loose surfaces versus highway driving. Choose a pattern that leans toward quieter, closely packed blocks if you spend most time on-road, or a more open, self-cleaning design for frequent off-pavement use.
Tread Life and Durability
Tread life affects long-term ownership cost and convenience. Tires with deeper, reinforced tread typically last longer in abrasion-heavy conditions, but longevity also depends on compound and driving style. Look for manufacturer treadwear ratings and independent wear data where available.
Durability also covers the tire carcass and sidewall construction. Reinforced sidewalls resist punctures and damage from rocks, which is useful if you stray from paved roads often. Expect a tradeoff: more reinforcement can mean a stiffer ride.
Ride Comfort and Road Noise
All terrain tires vary widely in how much noise and vibration they transmit into the cabin. Tire block size, pitch sequencing, and shoulder design all influence perceived road noise. On a Subaru Forester, excessive noise can make daily commutes tiring, so consider options that emphasize quieter tread layouts if comfort is a priority.
Ride comfort is affected by sidewall flexibility as well. Softer sidewalls absorb bumps better but may sacrifice some handling precision. Decide whether you prefer a smoother ride or firmer feedback for spirited driving.
Load Rating and Speed Capability
Choosing a tire with the correct load rating is essential to maintain the vehicle's safety margins, especially when carrying cargo or passengers. The speed rating indicates the tire's designed performance envelope; matching or exceeding the vehicle's specified rating preserves handling characteristics and stability.
Verify that any tire you consider meets the Forester's load index and speed requirements. Underrated tires can overheat under load, while overrated options may not materially benefit everyday use but could affect ride quality.
Size Fitment and Rolling Circumference
Tire size affects clearance, gearing feel, and speedometer accuracy. Larger diameter tires can increase ground clearance but may rub on suspension components or alter gearing. Rolling circumference influences speedometer and odometer readings, as well as effective final drive behavior.
Stick to sizes that are approved for the Forester's wheels and suspension, or understand the tradeoffs if you choose an alternative size. Proper sizing preserves handling, prevents rubbing, and keeps traction control and ABS systems functioning as intended.
FAQ
How often should I rotate all terrain tires on my Subaru Forester?
Rotate tires every 5,000 to 8,000 miles or follow the vehicle manufacturer interval, whichever comes first. Regular rotation evens out wear across the tread, which helps extend overall tread life and preserves balanced handling.
Are all terrain tires noisy compared with highway tires?
All terrain tires tend to be louder than dedicated highway tires because of their more aggressive tread patterns. Noise levels vary by pattern and construction, so some all terrain designs include noise-reducing features that make them comparable to touring tires on pavement.
Will switching to all terrain tires affect my Forester’s fuel economy?
You may see a modest reduction in fuel economy due to increased rolling resistance and heavier construction in some all terrain models. The impact usually depends on tread aggressiveness and tire weight, so choosing a balanced design minimizes fuel penalty while providing extra traction.
Can I use all terrain tires year-round on my Forester?
Many all terrain tires are suitable for year-round use, including in light winter conditions, but performance varies. If you encounter heavy snow or icy roads regularly, dedicated winter tires remain the safest choice for cold-season driving.
How do I know if a tire size will fit without rubbing?
Check the Forester’s recommended wheel and tire sizes in the owner manual or door placard and compare dimensions like overall diameter and width. Measuring available clearance around the wheel well and considering suspension travel helps prevent rubbing during turns or when loaded.
Does treadwear warranty matter for all terrain tires?
Treadwear warranties can provide insight into expected longevity but they are not guarantees. Warranties may be prorated and conditional on proper maintenance. Use the warranty as one factor alongside real-world durability reports and tread compound information.
How We Chose the Best Subaru Forester All Terrain Tires
We started by filtering for tires sized to fit Subaru Forester wheel and suspension limits and that meet the vehicle load and speed requirements. Key evaluation criteria included wet traction, tread life estimates, and noise and ride comfort to reflect daily driving and light off-road use. We also assessed tread pattern versatility for mixed surfaces, sidewall strength for occasional rough terrain, and overall durability ratings from user feedback and manufacturer specifications. Tires that only target extreme off-road conditions or that require suspension or rim modifications were excluded. We prioritized options that balance everyday road manners with added grip off pavement, while excluding specialty race, winter-only, or heavy-truck commercial tires that do not suit Forester usage.
Our full evaluation process is outlined in our review methodology.
Conclusion
When choosing all terrain tires for a Subaru Forester, prioritize wet traction, appropriate load rating, and a tread pattern that matches how often you will go off pavement. Balance durability and comfort to suit daily driving plus occasional adventures. Expect tradeoffs between off-road bite and on-road refinement; select the attributes that matter most to your driving style and the typical conditions you face.
Explore More:
- Check out all Subaru Forester parts & accessories
- Explore Wheels & Tires
- Browse all Auto Parts
