Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support my research and content. Read my full affiliate disclosure here.
Choosing the right exterior door handle for your Subaru Forester matters more than it seems. A well-fitting handle keeps doors secure, ensures smooth operation, and reduces the chance of roadside failures that complicate daily driving.This guide highlights the shortlisted top picks in the category and explains the evaluation criteria we used, including fitment accuracy and material durability. Read on to understand what to look for and how each factor affects real-world use.
Looking for other parts? See all Subaru Forester parts & accessories.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Best overall The best all-around choice for most situations | Dorman 81207 Exterior Door Handle, Rear (Right/Left), Smooth Black |  |
| Best quality Built to a higher standard if you want something more solid | Dorman 82703 Front Driver Side Exterior Door Handle — Black |  |
| Best Value The sweet spot between price and what you get | Garage-Pro Exterior Rear Door Handle Compatible with 2014-2018 Subaru Forester (Primed) |  |
| Best Budget The cheapest option that still gets the job done reliably | Auto Dynasty Front Left Exterior Door Handle with Keyhole (Textured Black) |  |
| Highest Rated A top-rated pick with lots of positive feedback | Dorman 79805 Front Passenger Exterior Door Handle (Smooth Black, Right) |  |
| Most popular A crowd favorite that many people choose with confidence | TRQ Front Driver Side Exterior Door Handle, Textured Black (No Passive Entry) |  |
| Best Seller A high-volume bestseller chosen again and again | KarParts360 Exterior Door Handle for Subaru Forester Front Driver Side (Textured Black) |  |
1. Dorman 81207 Exterior Door Handle, Rear (Right/Left), Smooth Black
| Material | Plastic |
|---|---|
| Handle Attachment Mechanism | screw |
| Hand Orientation | Ambidextrous |
| Included Components | Dorman 81207: Exterior Door Handle Rear Right/Left |
This Dorman exterior rear door handle is a direct replacement meant to recreate the factory fit and appearance on compatible vehicles. It installs in place of the original using the vehicle’s existing fasteners and screws and is supplied in a flat black finish that can be painted to match the vehicle. Typical use is a like-for-like repair when a rear door handle is broken, scuffed, or missing; the design aims to mirror the OEM contours so the handle mates with the stock linkage and latch. Practical benefits include an easy-to-install, position-specific replacement that saves a trip to the dealer and restores door function. Limitations to note are that the finish is plain black and may require paint if matching a chrome-accented handle, and fitment depends on selecting the correct side and position for the vehicle and trim. A small number of buyers reported fitment errors, so confirming exact vehicle trim before ordering is important.
Best for: Buyers seeking a balanced, practical replacement that restores rear door function and appearance without dealer pricing, favoring reliability and convenience.
Less Ideal for: If you want a ready-made chrome-matched or premium finished handle, or you prefer dealer-original parts for warranty reasons, consider alternative sources.
- Engineered to match factory appearance and function for compatible models
- Position-specific design reduces modification during installation
- Easy installation that uses existing attachment points and screws
- Supply includes a rear right/left unit so you get the replacement piece you need
- Matte black finish is not a color match for chrome-trimmed handles and may require painting
- Fit depends on exact trim and year so incorrect selection can result in mismatch
Verdict: A straightforward, cost-effective rear door handle replacement that restores factory-style fit and function for compatible vehicles but may need painting to match chrome trims.
2. Dorman 82703 Front Driver Side Exterior Door Handle — Black
| Hand Orientation | Left |
|---|---|
| Material | Alloy Steel |
| Lock Type | No Lock |
| Handle Attachment Mechanism | bolt |
| Included Components | Exterior Door Handle Front Left |
This Dorman front driver-side exterior door handle replaces the factory unit on specific Subaru Forester years and is designed to match original fit and look while keeping installation straightforward. It is typically used when the stock handle is cracked, faded, or failing; installation requires removing the interior door panel and reattaching the handle with the vehicle's bolt mounting points. The handle is made from alloy steel with a machined black finish and uses a bolt attachment mechanism that aligns with the factory mounting locations. Users report OEM-like fit and solid feel, though some installers note the rod retaining clip may be weaker than the original and that you might reuse some fasteners from the vehicle. The practical benefit is a near-factory replacement appearance and dependable operation without the dealer markups. Expect a modest installation time and plan for basic hand tools and patience with door panel removal and window positioning during the job.
Best for: Performance-oriented buyers seeking a high-quality, factory-style replacement that restores original function and appearance on their Subaru Forester and who are comfortable performing or overseeing a hands-on repair.
Less Ideal for: Buyers who want a plug-and-play swap with all fasteners and clips included or those unwilling to remove an interior door panel should consider a professional installation or a different solution.
- Engineered to match factory fit and appearance for select Subaru Forester years
- Alloy steel construction provides a solid, OEM-like feel
- Bolt attachment aligns with factory mounting points for straightforward replacement
- Machined black finish blends with original exterior styling
- Does not include replacement mounting screws or some small clips that installers may need to reuse from the vehicle
- Not a universal part — fits only specific Subaru Forester model years so verification is required
Verdict: A factory-style, alloy-steel replacement that restores fit and appearance on compatible Subaru Forester years, but plan to supply small fasteners or clips during installation.
3. Garage-Pro Exterior Rear Door Handle Compatible with 2014-2018 Subaru Forester (Primed)
| Handle Type | Pull Handle |
|---|---|
| Material Type | Metal, Plastic |
| Handle Material | Stainless Steel |
| Included Components | Installation Hardware |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 1-year Garage-Pro unlimited-mileage warranty |
This Garage-Pro exterior rear door handle is a direct-fit replacement designed for Subaru Forester models from 2014 to 2018 that do not use a smart entry system. It arrives primed and built from metal and plastic with a stainless steel handle material, and it includes installation hardware for a straightforward swap of the rear driver or passenger side handle. The part matches factory attachment points and accepts the vehicle key lock configuration used on non-smart-entry doors, so installation is largely a bolt-on job for DIYers or shops familiar with Subaru trim panels. Practical benefits include a factory-style look when painted, a stainless steel grip for durability, and an interchange-compatible part number set for easier verification. Limitations are that it is sold individually so you must order the correct side and it is not set up for smart key or electronic entry features, which makes it unsuitable when replacing a smart-entry equipped handle.
Best for: Practical optimizers looking to repair a non-smart-entry Forester affordably and restore factory appearance without paying for dealer parts.
Less Ideal for: Owners who need a smart-entry compatible handle or those who prefer to replace both sides together without buying separate units.
- Direct-fit replacement tailored for 2014–2018 Subaru Forester rear doors without smart entry
- Primed finish ready for paint to match the vehicle
- Includes installation hardware for a simpler installation
- Stainless steel handle material improves durability and appearance
- Not compatible with smart key or smart-entry door systems
- Sold individually so both sides require separate purchases
Verdict: A budget-friendly, direct-fit primed rear door handle that restores factory-style function and appearance for non-smart-entry Subaru Forester models.
4. Auto Dynasty Front Left Exterior Door Handle with Keyhole (Textured Black)
| Handle Type | Pull Handle |
|---|---|
| Lock Type | Key Lock |
| Hand Orientation | Left |
| Material Type | Steel / ABS Plastic |
This Auto Dynasty front left exterior door handle is a direct replacement designed to restore a damaged or worn driver-side handle on compatible Subaru Forester models. It pairs an ABS plastic grip with alloy steel mounting components for a factory-style look and uses the original attachment points so no drilling or body modification is required. The textured black finish matches many OEM trims and the built-in keyhole keeps mechanical access intact for vehicles that use a keyed driver door. Installation is intended to be straightforward for experienced DIYers but the listing advises professional installation if you are not comfortable working behind the door panel. Expect a functional, budget-friendly replacement that prioritizes appearance and basic durability; it does not include instructions or additional hardware and may lack the fit-and-finish of higher-end factory replacements.
Best for: Budget-conscious owners seeking an affordable, visually matching driver-side handle to repair a Subaru Forester and restore keyed access without buying a new OEM assembly.
Less Ideal for: Owners seeking perfect factory-level fit, exact OEM cosmetic finish, or a plug-and-play fit with included instructions and hardware should consider a factory replacement or dealer part instead.
- Direct replacement design that uses factory mounting points for an easier swap
- Textured black finish provides a close visual match to factory exterior trims
- Includes a keyed handle option to retain mechanical access
- Constructed from ABS plastic and alloy steel for basic outdoor durability
- No installation instructions or additional hardware included
- Fit-and-finish may be less refined than genuine factory parts
Verdict: A wallet-friendly direct-replacement driver-side handle that restores keyed access and appearance on compatible Subaru Forester models.
5. Dorman 79805 Front Passenger Exterior Door Handle (Smooth Black, Right)
| Included Components | Exterior Door Handle Front Right without keyhole |
|---|---|
| Material Type | Plastic |
| Handle Material | Alloy Steel |
| Hand Orientation | Right |
| Handle Attachment Mechanism | bolt |
This Dorman 79805 is a direct-replacement front passenger exterior door handle intended to restore outside door operation when the original handle fails. It is sold as the right-side, smooth black lever without a keyhole and installs using the factory bolt attachment points. Typical use is a DIY or shop replacement on compatible Subaru Forester years listed by the manufacturer; the plastic handle body with alloy-steel internal components aims to reproduce the look and operation of the factory part. Benefits include straightforward bolt-on fitment for matching model years, an easy-install design that shortens repair time, and a manufacturer focus on improved sealing and metal components to reduce future failures. Limitations are fitment sensitivity across trims and years—several buyers reported mismatches or gaps on certain vehicles—so confirm your exact year and trim before ordering. Expect a practical, lower-cost alternative to dealer parts that can return a stuck or broken handle to service when it matches your vehicle.
Best for: Reliability-focused buyers who prioritize restoring proper door function with a practical replacement that keeps the vehicle usable and avoids dealer-level expense.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need an exact factory-matched finish or who cannot tolerate any risk of fitment variance should consider sourcing an OEM factory-quality handle or consulting a dealer for exact-match parts.
- Designed to match factory fit and appearance for listed vehicle years
- Easy bolt-on installation for quick DIY or shop replacement
- Uses alloy-steel internal components intended to improve durability over time
- Sold as a vehicle-position specific piece to simplify ordering
- Fitment can be inconsistent across model years and trims requiring careful verification
- Plastic exterior may not match original texture or long-term wear on some vehicles
Verdict: A practical, easy-to-install right-side replacement that restores exterior door function for compatible Forester years when fitment is confirmed.
6. TRQ Front Driver Side Exterior Door Handle, Textured Black (No Passive Entry)
| Material | Plastic |
|---|---|
| Hand Orientation | Left |
| Special Feature | Easy to Install |
| Lock Type | Key Lock |
This TRQ front driver-side exterior door handle is a direct replacement for Subaru Forester models listed in the fitment chart and is intended for cars without passive keyless entry. It installs like a factory-style component and is supplied pre-assembled to make a DIY swap quicker and easier. The textured black plastic finish hides light scratches and matches many factory trims, and TRQ provides compatibility guidance and installation videos that help reduce installation time for a home mechanic. Practical benefits include straightforward fit and a lower cost than factory replacements, plus a design that includes the necessary latch and lock cutouts for a plug-and-play swap on compatible Foresters. Limitations are that it is plastic rather than metal, so it will not have the premium feel or potential long-term durability of a metal handle, and a few buyers report minor fit and alignment issues on some vehicle variants, which could require light adjustment during installation. It is a good convenience-focused option when you want a quick, budget-friendly replacement and are comfortable doing a simple door panel removal and install.
Best for: Convenience-driven owners who prioritize a quick, budget-friendly DIY repair and want a ready-to-install replacement that closely matches factory appearance.
Less Ideal for: Buyers seeking a metal or premium-feel handle, or those who require a passive keyless-entry compatible replacement should consider other options.
- Pre-assembled, direct-fit design intended to speed up DIY installation
- Textured black finish conceals everyday wear and matches factory trim
- Lower cost alternative to factory replacement handles
- Manufacturer provides installation videos and a compatibility chart
- Plastic construction feels less premium and may be less durable than metal alternatives
- Some users report small fit or alignment issues that can require adjustment
- Not compatible with vehicles that have passive keyless entry
Verdict: A convenient, budget-friendly direct-fit plastic replacement for Forester drivers without passive entry who want a quick DIY fix with minimal fuss.
7. KarParts360 Exterior Door Handle for Subaru Forester Front Driver Side (Textured Black)
| Compatible Models | Subaru Forester 1998-2002 |
|---|---|
| Position | Front driver side |
| Material | Plastic |
| Safety Rating | DOT Certified |
| Lock Type | Key Lock |
This KarParts360 exterior door handle is a direct aftermarket replacement for the front driver side of Subaru Forester models from 1998 through 2002. It installs in place of the factory handle and is intended for everyday use as a functional exterior latch with a textured black finish that matches Base and S/L trims. Made of plastic and sold as a single left-hand unit, the handle includes a keyed lock option and is DOT certified for safety. Practical benefits include straightforward bolt-on installation and compatibility with the OEM part and Partslink numbers listed, which reduces fitment guesswork. Because it is an aftermarket part rather than factory-manufactured, finish texture and long-term durability may differ modestly from a factory replacement, and painted color matching will require additional work if you need a perfect color blend. The product is best when you need a cost-effective, serviceable replacement that restores door function quickly without extensive modification.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize low-risk, straightforward repairs and want a reliable, budget-conscious replacement that restores door function with minimal hassle.
Less Ideal for: Those seeking an exact factory-produced part or a perfect painted color match should consider sourcing a factory-quality handle or professional color-matched replacement.
- Direct replacement designed to match OEM part and Partslink numbers for correct fitment
- Textured black finish that fits Base and S/L trim aesthetics
- DOT certified safety rating
- Simple bolt-on installation for quick repair
- Aftermarket plastic construction may not match factory finish or longevity exactly
- Sold as a single unit so passenger-side replacement requires a second purchase
Verdict: A practical, budget-friendly replacement that restores door function on 1998–2002 Foresters quickly, though it is an aftermarket plastic unit rather than a factory-produced handle.
Choosing the Right Subaru Forester Exterior Door Handle: Key Factors to Consider
Fitment Accuracy
Fitment accuracy is critical because a handle that does not align precisely with the Forester's door latch and mounting points will cause improper operation and possible damage. Measure mounting hole spacing and verify the handle's orientation to ensure it matches the vehicle's door design.
Even small differences in bracket geometry or pivot location can lead to increased wear or a handle that feels loose. Confirm whether the handle is listed specifically for the Subaru Forester model year you own and whether it replaces the factory mounting hardware or requires adapters.
Material And Finish
Material and finish determine corrosion resistance, tactile feel, and long-term aesthetics. Handles made from zinc alloy, stainless steel, or reinforced plastic each have different strengths; metal options often feel sturdier while engineered plastics can resist dents and chips.
The finish must resist UV fading and salt or road grime to avoid flaking or rust. Consider whether the finish is painted, chrome-plated, or powder-coated and how it will match your existing trim over time.
Mechanical Reliability
Mechanical reliability covers the internal pivot, return spring, and latch actuation. A reliable mechanism operates smoothly through repeated cycles without binding or excessive looseness. Look for designs with reinforced pivot points and replaceable springs when available.
Poorly engineered mechanisms can lead to premature failure, sticking in cold weather, or intermittent latching that compromises door security. Assessing the build quality of moving parts helps predict long-term performance.
Compatibility With Locks And Trim
Compatibility with existing locks, key cylinders, and trim pieces affects both function and appearance. Some handles are designed to accept the original lock cylinder, while others require a separate keyed assembly. Verify whether the handle preserves access to the key slot or integrates with remote locking components.
Additionally, check how the handle interfaces with surrounding trim to avoid gaps or interference. A handle that does not seat flush can trap moisture or cause wind noise.
Installation Complexity
Installation complexity ranges from simple bolt-on replacements to jobs requiring interior door panel removal and linkage adjustment. Understand the tools and skills needed, such as panel clips, torque specifications, and trim removal techniques.
If the installation involves interior access, plan for extra time to avoid damaging clips or weather seals. Clear instructions and included hardware can significantly reduce the likelihood of errors during fitting.
Availability Of Replacement Parts
Availability of replacement parts, such as springs, clips, or mounting screws, matters for long-term maintenance. Handles that allow individual component replacement can be more economical and sustainable than units that must be discarded when a single small part fails.
Consider whether mounting hardware is included and how easy it will be to source compatible components later. Readily available parts reduce downtime if a minor repair is needed.
How We Chose the Best Subaru Forester Exterior Door Handle
To create this list we focused on the attributes that matter most for Subaru Forester exterior door handle replacements. Key evaluation criteria included fitment accuracy to the Forester door and latch assembly, material and finish durability against weather and abrasion, mechanical reliability of the handle mechanism, and compatibility with existing lock and trim components. We also considered ease of installation, availability of replacement hardware, and the range of finish options to match the vehicle's appearance.Products were excluded if they lacked clear fitment specifications for the Subaru Forester, used undocumented or low-grade materials, or did not provide sufficient mounting hardware or instructions. We prioritized handles that offer predictable long-term operation, straightforward installation, and durable finishes, while excluding entries that relied on vague claims or insufficient compatibility data.
Our full evaluation process is outlined in our review methodology.
FAQ
How do I know if I need a full exterior door handle replacement or a minor repair?
If the handle is loose, sticks, or fails to retract, that often indicates a mechanical issue that may require replacement. Minor issues like a broken clip or a worn spring can sometimes be repaired, but persistent binding or visible damage to the handle body usually warrants a full replacement.
Can I install an exterior door handle myself for a Subaru Forester?
Many owners can perform a handle replacement with basic hand tools, but some steps may require removing the interior door panel and working with linkage clips. If you are comfortable with trim removal and following instructions, the job is often doable at home. Otherwise, professional installation removes the risk of damaging seals or clips.
What should I check to ensure the new handle matches my Forester's finish?
Compare the handle's listed finish type and color photos to your vehicle. Confirm whether the finish is painted, chrome, or matte and look for notes about UV resistance or powder coating. If exact matching is important, choose an option that specifies compatibility with your model's trim level.
Will replacing the exterior handle affect my car's locking system?
Replacing the handle should not affect the locking system if the new handle accepts the original lock cylinder or is designed to integrate with the existing mechanism. Verify compatibility with your vehicle's key cylinder and remote lock components to avoid unintended issues.
How long does a typical exterior door handle last on a Subaru Forester?
Lifespan depends on materials, exposure to the elements, and usage frequency. Well-made handles with corrosion-resistant finishes and robust mechanisms often last many years, while lower-grade units may show wear sooner. Regular inspection and addressing small issues early can extend service life.
Conclusion
When choosing a Subaru Forester exterior door handle, prioritize fitment accuracy, durable materials, and a reliable mechanism. Those factors most directly influence daily operation, longevity, and whether installation will be straightforward.Balance finish matching and availability of replacement parts with installation complexity. Focusing on the criteria above will help you select a handle that restores proper function and maintains the vehicle's appearance.
Explore More:
- Check out all Subaru Forester parts & accessories
- Explore Exterior Door Handles Maintenance & Repair Guides
- Explore Body & Exterior
- Browse all Auto Parts
