Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support my research and content. Read my full affiliate disclosure here.
If you drive a 2009-2013 Subaru Forester, choosing the right mirror matters for visibility, safety, and convenience. Replacing a damaged exterior mirror or a faulty powered unit affects how you see traffic, use integrated electronics, and maintain vehicle weatherproofing. This guide narrows the field to five top mirror options that match the Forester's fitment and electrical needs.We shortlisted mirrors that meet factory mounting patterns, wiring harness compatibility, and common feature sets such as power adjustment and heating. Below you will find practical evaluation criteria and guidance to help you pick the right replacement for regular driving, winter conditions, or when restoring a damaged assembly.
Looking for other parts? See all Subaru Forester parts & accessories.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Best Overall The best all-around choice for most situations | Garage-Pro Mirror Set Compatible with Subaru Forester 2011-2013 |  |
| Best Value The sweet spot between price and what you get | CAR MIRROR BAZAR Replacement Driver-Side Mirror Glass for 2009–2013 Subaru Forester |  |
| Best Budget The cheapest option that still gets the job done reliably | Fit System Driver Side Replacement Mirror Glass for Subaru Forester |  |
| Highest Rated A top-rated pick with lots of positive feedback | AutoTruckMirrorsUnlimited Driver Side Mirror Glass Replacement with Full Adhesive Pad |  |
| Most Popular A crowd favorite that many people choose with confidence | Magimaker Interior Rear View Mirror Replacement (92039FE001 / 92039FE000) |  |
1. Garage-Pro Mirror Set Compatible with Subaru Forester 2011-2013
| Auto Part Position | Left, Right |
|---|---|
| Mounting Type | Door Mount |
| Other Special Features | Power Adjust, Manual Folding, Non-Heated |
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
This Garage-Pro mirror set replaces both driver and passenger side exterior mirrors on Subaru Forester models from 2011 to 2013. It is a vehicle-specific direct-fit replacement supplied as a two-count set with paintable housings and power-adjust mirror glass, so you can mount them to the door and reconnect the factory power adjust controls. The mirrors are manual folding and non-heated, and the glass is convex to give a wider field of view. For everyday repairs and routine collision repairs this set delivers a near-factory fit and appearance and arrives ready for paint to match your car. Limitations to note are the lack of puddle lights, auto-dimming, blind spot indicators, and heating, so it does not include some convenience and safety extras found on higher-trim or newer mirrors. Installation is typical for door-mounted mirrors and aimed at DIY-savvy owners or shops doing a straightforward replacement.
Best for: Buyers who want a practical, near-factory replacement that restores appearance and basic function after damage or during a refresh without paying for premium features.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need heated mirrors, integrated safety features, or factory-style auto-dimming and lighting should consider upgraded or OEM options instead.
- Vehicle-specific direct fit for Subaru Forester 2011–2013 for easier installation
- Paintable housings let you match the vehicle color for a factory look
- Power-adjust glass maintains convenience of in-cab mirror control
- Set includes both left and right mirrors for full replacement
- No heated glass, puddle lights, auto-dimming, or blind spot features included
Verdict: A cost-effective, paintable direct-fit mirror pair that restores factory-style fit and power-adjust function for 2011–2013 Subaru Forester models.
2. CAR MIRROR BAZAR Replacement Driver-Side Mirror Glass for 2009–2013 Subaru Forester
| Auto Part Position | Front Left |
|---|---|
| Mounting Type | Stick on over broken glass or on the backing plate |
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
| Lens Curvature Description | Flat |
| Included Components | Adhesive Tape shaped to the glass contour |
This is a direct replacement driver-side mirror glass sized to match the 2009–2013 Subaru Forester driver mirror and meant to be stuck over a broken glass or onto an existing backing plate. It uses contoured automotive-grade double-sided adhesive that simplifies installation and improves heat transfer compared with small adhesive patches. The glass is real aluminum-back mirror material rather than a thin chrome spray so it resists fading and scratching better over time. Typical use is a quick homeowner repair: clean the backing plate, position the glass using the longest-diagonal measurement, peel the adhesive liner, and press into place. Limitations are that no backing plate or plastic housing is included and the part is flat in curvature, so it will not match mirrors that use a convex surface or an electronic round-dial mount. Fit depends on matching the pictured shape and diagonal measurement before ordering. For someone fixing a cracked or missing mirror on a Forester this offers a straightforward, durable swap if the mirror assembly itself is intact.
Best for: Buyers wanting a practical, do-it-yourself replacement to restore a broken driver-side mirror on a 2009–2013 Forester and who prioritize straightforward installation and durable mirror surface.
Less Ideal for: Do not choose this if your mirror assembly is damaged, missing its backing plate, or if your factory mirror uses a pronounced convex curve or electronic adjustment mount.
- Vehicle-specific shape and sizing for 2009–2013 Forester driver side fit
- Automotive-grade contoured double-sided adhesive for easier installation and better heat transfer
- Aluminum-backed real mirror glass more durable than painted chrome alternatives
- No backing plate or plastic housing included so you must reuse or replace the mount separately
- Flat lens curvature may not match convex factory mirrors
Verdict: A simple, durable DIY replacement mirror glass tuned for 2009–2013 Forester drivers who want an easy install and long-lasting reflective surface.
3. Fit System Driver Side Replacement Mirror Glass for Subaru Forester
| Auto Part Position | Left |
|---|---|
| Mounting Type | Door Mount |
| Other Special Features of the Product | Non-Heated |
| Lens Curvature Description | Flat |
| Included Components | Mounting Tape |
This replacement mirror glass is a straightforward, low-cost fix for a cracked or missing driver-side mirror on a 2009–2013 Subaru Forester. It is a flat glass designed to stick onto the existing mirror housing using the included mounting tape, and the package includes step-by-step instructions so installation can be done at home with basic tools. The glass is non-heated and has no turn signal capability, but it is sized to match the factory housing and is compatible with both manual and heated power mirror assemblies if you only need the reflective surface replaced. Because it is a simple stick-on part, expect a quick repair and restored visibility without paying for a full mirror assembly. The main limitations are the lack of heating for defogging and no integrated indicators, so it does not restore advanced functions; users wanting those features should replace the full mirror unit instead.
Best for: Buyers who want the cheapest practical repair to restore side-view visibility on a Forester and prefer a quick DIY fix over replacing the entire mirror assembly.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need a heated mirror for defogging, integrated turn signals, or who prefer replacing the whole mirror housing for factory-quality functionality.
- Low-cost way to replace cracked driver-side mirror glass
- Included mounting tape and instructions make installation quick and do-it-yourself friendly
- Designed to fit the Subaru Forester driver-side housing and works with manual or powered mirror assemblies
- No heating element so it will not defog or melt ice
- Does not include turn signal or other integrated mirror features
Verdict: A very affordable, do-it-yourself replacement glass that restores driver-side visibility on 2009–2013 Foresters without restoring heated or indicator functions.
4. AutoTruckMirrorsUnlimited Driver Side Mirror Glass Replacement with Full Adhesive Pad
| Auto Part Position | Left |
|---|---|
| Mounting Type | Door Mount |
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
| Operation Mode | Power |
| Material Type | Glass |
This replacement mirror glass is a straightforward direct-fit option for the 2009–2013 Subaru Forester driver side mirror that replaces the glass only and uses a full-size double-sided adhesive pad for installation. It is intended for power mirrors and has a flat lens curvature; the kit contains the glass and a contoured adhesive pad so you do not need a backing plate for typical adhesive installations. In practice the adhesive pad makes installation quick and secure and the automotive-grade glass reduces headlight glare for clearer night driving. Because the product is non-heated and ships without a plastic backing plate, it is best when your original backing plate is intact and your vehicle does not require mirror heating. The seller provides dimensions and fit guidance to confirm shape before buying, which helps avoid ordering the wrong style. For someone needing a reliable, low-cost repair to restore mirror clarity and viewability, this is a practical DIY replacement that installs in minutes.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize dependable, straightforward repairs and want a factory-style mirror glass replacement they can install themselves to restore clear visibility.
Less Ideal for: Drivers who need a heated mirror element or whose mirror backing plate is broken should look for a complete heated glass or full assembly instead.
- Includes a full-size, contoured double-sided adhesive pad for secure, easy installation
- Automotive-grade glass designed to reduce headlight glare for improved night visibility
- Vehicle-specific fit for 2009–2013 Subaru Forester driver side to simplify selection
- Quick do-it-yourself install that restores mirror function without replacing the whole assembly
- Non-heated glass and no plastic backing plate included, so not suitable if your mirror requires heating or a damaged backing plate
Verdict: A reliable, vehicle-specific glass replacement that lets Forester owners quickly restore mirror clarity with an easy adhesive installation.
5. Magimaker Interior Rear View Mirror Replacement (92039FE001 / 92039FE000)
| Mounting Type | Windshield Mount |
|---|---|
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
| Lens Curvature Description | Convex |
| Operation Mode | Manual |
| Material Type | Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) |
This Magimaker interior rearview mirror is a manual, windshield-mounted replacement designed to fit specific Subaru vehicles including Forester 2009-2013. It installs in the stock mirror location and offers a rectangular, slightly convex reflective surface that improves rear visibility compared with a flat mirror. The housing is injection-molded ABS intended to match the look and mount of the original part number 92039FE001 / 92039FE000. For routine daily driving it functions like a factory mirror and is useful when replacing a cracked or missing unit. It does not include electronic features since it is manual, so expect no auto-dimming or built-in sensors. Buyers should confirm the part numbers and mounting stud match their vehicle before purchase. The product comes as a single mirror and aims to provide a durable, low-cost factory-style replacement rather than an upgraded aftermarket option.
Best for: Buyers who want a budget-conscious, like-for-like replacement mirror for a 2009–2013 Forester and prefer to rely on products with positive user feedback and clear part-number matching.
Less Ideal for: Drivers seeking upgraded features such as auto-dimming, compass, or integrated electronics should consider higher-end aftermarket or factory-upgrade mirrors.
- Vehicle-specific fit for Subaru applications including Forester 2009-2013
- Durable ABS housing designed to match factory appearance
- Convex lens improves field of view over a flat mirror
- Straightforward windshield-mount installation as a direct replacement
- Manual operation only with no auto-dimming or integrated sensors
Verdict: A practical, factory-style manual replacement mirror for Forester owners who need a reliable, part-number-matching swap without electronic features.
Choosing the Right 2009-2013 Subaru Forester Mirror: Key Factors to Consider
Fit and Mounting Pattern
Correct fit is the foundation of a reliable mirror replacement. For the 2009-2013 Forester, the mirror base must align with the door mounting points and gasket profile to avoid gaps that let water and wind noise enter the cabin. A precise mounting pattern also ensures the mirror glass sits at the intended angle relative to the door and roofline, preserving the original field of view.
Poor fit can lead to vibrations, accelerated wear of adjustment motors, or water intrusion that damages internal wiring. When evaluating options, check whether the assembly lists direct fit for the 2009-2013 Forester and whether it includes the necessary mounting hardware and gasket. If the unit is listed as a universal fit, confirm that a vehicle-specific adapter or trim piece is included to prevent an improper installation.
Electrical Compatibility
Many Forester models in this range use powered mirror adjustment and, on higher trims or packages, heated glass. Electrical compatibility covers motor connector pinout, power and ground locations, and whether a vehicle harness taps into a defogger circuit for heated mirrors. Choosing a mirror with matching connectors avoids splicing or rewiring that can create failure points.
Consider whether the replacement supports the same number of adjustment axes and whether the control switch behavior is preserved. For heated mirrors, verify that the element is compatible with the Forester's voltage and that installation instructions note any required fuse or relay checks. If you plan to add features to a previously manual mirror, be prepared for additional wiring and potential switch upgrades.
Glass Type and Visibility
The mirror glass type directly affects night driving and lane-change visibility. Look for glass with anti-glare or slight tinting to reduce headlight glare, and consider convex or spotter-lens options if you need a wider field of view. Heated glass variants help keep the surface clear in cold climates, reducing the time you spend scraping ice or waiting for defrost to work.
Glass adhesion and backing quality also influence durability. Poorly bonded glass is more prone to popping or vibrating loose. Check for replacement glass availability if you expect to replace only the lens rather than the entire assembly, which can save labor time in the future.
Housing Durability and Finish
The mirror housing protects internal components from moisture, debris, and road impacts. On a vehicle like the Forester that sees varied weather, select housings made from impact-resistant plastics with robust paint or textured finishes that resist chipping. Sealing quality at joints and around the glass reduces water ingress that can corrode adjustment motors or electrical contacts.
Consider whether the replacement includes painted caps or comes primed for painting to match the vehicle color. UV resistance of the finish prevents premature fading. Also evaluate how the housing design manages drainage and whether integrated turn signal pockets or puddle lights, if present, are properly sealed.
Adjustability and Mechanism Quality
Smooth, reliable adjustment is essential for fine-tuning mirror aim and minimizing in-drive vibration. Mechanical quality covers the geared motor design, travel range, and how the mechanism resists backlash. Units with tight tolerances and stable gear trains hold position better under wind load and road vibration.
Manual folding or power folding mechanisms should operate without excessive play. If the unit offers power folding, confirm whether it integrates with existing vehicle controls or requires an aftermarket switch. A well-built mechanism reduces the likelihood of intermittent movement or failure after installation.
Serviceability and Replacement Parts
Serviceability matters because mirrors are frequently damaged by curb strikes or garage impacts. Options that allow the glass or cap to be replaced separately reduce future repair time and cost. Check for availability of replacement glass, covers, and motor assemblies that match the same mounting points.
Also consider how easy the assembly is to remove from the door without special tools. Manufacturers that provide clear instructions and include mounting hardware make DIY replacement more feasible. For independent installers, a design that minimizes door panel removal can lower labor time.
Understanding Factory Versus Aftermarket Fit
Replacement mirrors are offered either as direct-fit assemblies designed to match the factory mounting and wiring or as aftermarket universal designs that may require adapters. For the 2009-2013 Forester, direct-fit replacements are usually the simplest route because they replicate the original bolt pattern and connector layout.
When considering an aftermarket option, verify how it addresses mounting geometry and whether the manufacturer provides a Forester-specific harness or adapter. Improper fit can lead to wind noise and water leaks, so pay close attention to photos and fitment notes.
- Direct-fit assemblies match the original mounting and electrical connectors.
- Universal options may need adapters or wiring modifications.
- Check seller or manufacturer fitment notes for 2009-2013 Forester compatibility.
Wiring and Connector Tips for Installation
Before you start the swap, compare the mirror connector on your vehicle to the replacement part. Even when connectors look similar, pin assignments can differ. Labeling the harness or taking photos helps maintain correct orientation during reassembly.
If splicing is required, use weatherproof connectors and heat-shrink tubing to protect against corrosion. For heated mirrors, confirm that the defroster circuit is fused correctly and that any added wiring does not overload existing circuits.
- Match connector shape and pin count before attempting to plug in.
- Use dielectric grease on electrical contacts to reduce corrosion.
- Test motor and heating functions before final reassembly.
Heated Glass and Cold-Weather Considerations
In climates where ice and snow are common, heated mirror glass can significantly improve visibility and convenience. Heated elements help clear frost and reduce the time the mirror is obscured while you warm up the car. Confirm that the replacement mirror specifies heated glass and how it ties into the Forester's existing defrost circuitry.
If you replace an unheated unit with a heated one, expect to route an additional feed and possibly add a relay or fuse. Verify that the vehicle's electrical capacity can handle the extra load, and follow wiring best practices to prevent unintended electrical issues.
- Heated glass helps clear frost and condensation faster.
- Installing heated units may require additional wiring or relays.
- Ensure the replacement heating element matches the vehicle voltage and fuse ratings.
Options for Improved Visibility
Some mirror lenses offer wider-angle or spotter sections to reduce blind spots. For Forester owners who frequently drive on highways or in urban environments, a subtle convex area can make lane changes safer by increasing the visible field without drastic distortion.
If you choose a lens with a wider field of view, re-aim the mirror carefully after installation to account for perceived distance changes. A professional alignment of the mirror aim is not usually necessary, but a short test drive to confirm sightlines is recommended.
- Wider-angle glass expands peripheral visibility.
- Spotter lenses help detect vehicles in adjacent lanes.
- Re-aim mirrors after installation to compensate for lens curvature.
Painted Caps and Cosmetic Matching
Cosmetic match matters if you want the replacement mirror to blend with your Forester's finish. Some assemblies come primed for painting, while others include painted caps to match common factory colors. If a painted match is important, choose an option that either lists compatible factory colors or comes primed for professional painting.
Keep in mind that slight color variations, especially on older vehicles, are normal due to sun exposure and fading. Allow time for professional painting and curing if you opt to have caps painted to match the body.
- Primed caps let you paint to match vehicle color.
- Pre-painted caps may not be an exact match for aged paint.
- Consider ordering caps and mirror bodies together for a consistent finish.
Still looking for the perfect fit?
Select your Subaru Forester configuration to see the most relevant Mirrors recommendations
How We Chose the Best 2009-2013 Subaru Forester Mirror
We focused on attributes that matter for owners of 2009-2013 Subaru Forester models and applied a consistent editorial filter to produce a practical shortlist. Primary evaluation criteria included exact fit and mounting alignment to the Forester door, ensuring the mirror assembly matches factory bolt patterns and mounting gasket shapes. Electrical compatibility was assessed for powered mirrors, checking motor control, wiring harness pinouts, and whether heated elements tie into the vehicle's defog/defrost circuits. Lens and glass quality were evaluated for clarity, anti-glare performance, and the availability of heated glass where applicable.Durability and weather resistance were considered, with attention to seal design, corrosion-resistant fasteners, and housing materials that withstand road salt and UV exposure. Adjustability and mechanism smoothness were examined for both manual and power units to reduce vibration and allow precise aiming. Ease of installation and access to replacement glass or covers was another filter, favoring assemblies that allow straightforward swap-outs without major door trim removal.We excluded mirrors that require significant body modification, non-standard mounting adapters, or those lacking documentation for 2009-2013 Forester fitment. The resulting options prioritize correct fit, dependable electrical connections, and serviceability for typical owners and independent installers.
Our full evaluation process is outlined in our review methodology.
FAQ
Can I replace just the mirror glass on my 2009-2013 Forester?
Often you can replace only the glass if the housing and mechanism are intact. Many replacement glass pieces are sold to fit the Forester, which reduces cost and labor compared with swapping the whole assembly.
Will a powered mirror from another trim level fit my Forester?
It depends. Fitment is determined by mounting pattern and electrical connector compatibility. If the mounting and harness match the 2009-2013 Forester, a powered upgrade may be possible, but additional wiring or switch changes could be required.
How do I know if my replacement mirror needs a new gasket or seal?
Inspect the existing gasket for cracks, compression set, or missing material. If the original shows wear or the replacement does not include a new gasket, install a new seal to prevent water intrusion and wind noise.
Are heated mirrors worth it for the Forester in snowy regions?
Heated mirrors provide noticeable convenience in cold climates by clearing frost and reducing buildup. They add wiring complexity but often improve morning visibility and reduce time spent clearing ice.
What should I test after installing a replacement mirror?
Verify mechanical adjustment across all axes, confirm any heating function works when the defogger is activated, and check for secure mounting without vibration. Also look for water leaks around the base after a rain or wash.
Final Verdict
When replacing a mirror on a 2009-2013 Subaru Forester, prioritize direct-fit assemblies that match the factory mounting and electrical connectors. Decide early whether you need heated glass or upgraded visibility features, because electrical compatibility and wiring needs drive complexity and installation time.Balance durability, glass quality, and serviceability to match how you use the vehicle. If you value straightforward installation and long-term reliability, choose an option that offers the correct fit, weatherproof sealing, and accessible replacement parts to keep the Forester safe and functional on the road.
Explore More:
- Check out all Subaru Forester parts & accessories
- Explore Mirrors Maintenance & Repair Guides
- Explore Body & Exterior
- Browse all Auto Parts
