Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support my research and content. Read my full affiliate disclosure here.
If you own a 2009-2013 Subaru Forester, selecting the right floor mats can protect the interior from mud, snow, and daily wear while making cleanup simpler. The wrong mats can shift, trap moisture, or fail to cover high-wear areas, so fit and material matter more than you might expect.This guide presents the top shortlisted floor mats for the 2009-2013 Forester, chosen for fit quality, durability, and ease of maintenance. Below you will find what we evaluated and practical considerations to match mats to how you use the vehicle, whether you need heavy-duty winter protection or low-profile interior coverage. Read on for a clear framework to pick the right option for your Forester.
Looking for other parts? See all Subaru Forester parts & accessories.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Best Overall Floor Mats The best all-around choice balancing fit, durability, and looks | ANBINGO All-Weather TPE Floor Mats for Subaru Forester (2009–2013) — 3-Piece Set |  |
| Best Premium Floor Mats Higher-end materials and finish for long-lasting protection and style | WeatherTech FloorLiner Custom Fit Floor Mats for 2009–2013 Subaru Forester |  |
| Best All-Weather Floor Mats Molded, waterproof mats designed for mud, snow, and spills | Wayhigh All-Weather Floor Mats and Seatback Cargo Liner for Subaru Forester 2009–2013 |  |
| Best Heavy-Duty Floor Mats Extra-thick, reinforced mats built for rugged use and longevity | 3D MAXpider Kagu All-Weather Floor Liners for Subaru Forester 2009–2013 (Full Set) |  |
| Best Custom-Fit Floor Mats Precisely contoured mats that match vehicle floor shape and anchors | CARTIST Custom-Fit Floor Mats and Cargo Liner for Subaru Forester 2009–2013 |  |
1. ANBINGO All-Weather TPE Floor Mats for Subaru Forester (2009–2013) — 3-Piece Set
Best Overall Floor Mats
| Compatible Vehicle | Subaru Forester 2009–2013 |
|---|---|
| Material Type | Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE) |
| Included Components | Driver front, passenger front, connected 2nd-row rear liners |
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
These ANBINGO floor mats are a custom-fit, all-weather TPE liner set made for Subaru Forester model years 2009 through 2013. The set includes driver and passenger front liners plus a connected rear liner that covers the second row, and the company says the molds come from 3D scans for an accurate fit and precise openings for factory floor hooks. In daily use the high sidewalls and textured channels trap water, snow, and debris to keep it off the carpet, and the TPE material is flexible in very cold weather yet resists deformation in heat. They clean quickly with a hose or wipe-down and snap into position for easy removal. Practical limitations are that this is a model-specific fit so it only suits the stated Forester years, and appearance is functional rather than premium carpet-style luxury. For owners who want straightforward, near-seamless protection that is simple to clean, these deliver reliably.
Best for: Buyers who want a practical, easy-to-maintain set of liners that provide reliable, near-seamless protection for a 2009–2013 Forester and prioritize durability and containment over luxury appearance.
Less Ideal for: If you want plush carpeted mats for a dressier interior or universal liners that fit many vehicles, these custom Forester-specific TPE liners are not the right choice.
- Vehicle-specific 3D-scanned fit with openings for factory floor hooks to keep liners in place
- Durable TPE material rated to remain flexible in extreme cold and resist deformation in heat
- High side edges and textured surface contain liquids, mud, and debris effectively
- Easy to clean and remove; rinse with water or wipe for fast maintenance
- Design prioritizes function over premium styling, so look is utilitarian rather than upscale
Verdict: The best all-around floor mats that balance durable materials, accurate coverage, easy cleaning, and attractive appearance for most owners.
2. WeatherTech FloorLiner Custom Fit Floor Mats for 2009–2013 Subaru Forester
Best Premium Floor Mats
| Compatible vehicle years | 2009-2013 Subaru Forester (select models) |
|---|---|
| Coverage area | 1st & 2nd Row |
| Material Type | Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE) |
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
These WeatherTech FloorLiner are heavy-duty, vehicle-specific floor mats engineered to cover the front and rear footwells of compatible 2009–2013 Subaru Forester models. Made from Thermoplastic Elastomer with a rigid core and high sidewalls, the liners resist deformation while directing water, mud, and snow into deep channels and a lower containment reservoir. They install in place of factory mats and use retention points to limit shifting. Practical benefits include easy cleaning with soap and water, recyclable, latex- and PVC-free construction to minimize odors, and a precision laser-measured fit that preserves carpet and resale value. The design emphasizes coverage and containment rather than carpet-like comfort, so they add robust protection but feel firmer underfoot compared with softer all-weather mats. Buyers should confirm exact model-year fitment and be prepared to remove factory mats during installation; some vehicle options may require light trimming to clear subwoofers or speakers.
Best for: Shoppers who prioritize maximum protection, precision fit, and long-term durability over plush comfort and who want a tailored, high-quality floor liner for a 2009–2013 Forester.
Less Ideal for: Buyers who prefer a softer, carpet-like mat for ride comfort or those needing a universal, budget-oriented solution.
- Custom laser-measured shape for full coverage of front and rear footwells
- Rigid core and high sidewalls contain spills, snow, and mud effectively
- Deep surface channels route fluids to a lower reservoir to keep feet dry
- Made from recyclable TPE that is latex- and PVC-free to reduce odors
- Easy to clean with mild detergent and water
- Firm, rigid feel underfoot is less comfortable than softer all-weather mats
Verdict: The best premium floor mats for shoppers willing to pay more for superior materials, precision fit, refined styling, and longer-lasting wear.
3. Wayhigh All-Weather Floor Mats and Seatback Cargo Liner for Subaru Forester 2009–2013
Best All-Weather Floor Mats
| Compatible Vehicle | Subaru Forester 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 |
|---|---|
| Material Type | Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE) |
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
| Included Components | Front liners, 2nd row connected liner, trunk cargo liner, 2 seatback mats |
These Wayhigh mats provide full-coverage protection for a 2009–2013 Subaru Forester, including driver and passenger front liners, a connected second-row liner, a trunk cargo liner, and two seatback mats. Molded from thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) and produced from 3D laser scans of the vehicle, the set fits the Forester's floor contours and raised edges help contain spills, slush, and road salt. The segmented rear design and Velcro straps on the seatback liners let you secure and remove pieces individually for cleaning or when you need more cargo flexibility. Installation is tool-free and cleaning is simple—rinse or wipe the mats and air-dry. The material stays flexible in very cold temperatures and resists deformation in heat, but because these are heavy-duty molded liners they add visual bulk compared with thin carpet-style mats and may not appeal to buyers wanting a minimalist look. Also the set is vehicle-specific, so it only fits the listed Forester years.
Best for: Drivers who regularly face wet, muddy, or snowy conditions and prioritize heavy-duty, waterproof interior protection for a Subaru Forester 2009–2013.
Less Ideal for: Buyers who prefer low-profile, carpeted floor mats for a dressier interior or those who want a universal-fit product that covers multiple vehicle models.
- Complete set includes front, connected second-row, trunk cargo liner, and two seatback mats for full interior protection
- TPE construction is durable, recyclable, and stays flexible across a wide temperature range
- Raised edges and custom molding trap liquids, mud, and debris to protect the factory carpet
- Segmented rear design and Velcro straps make the liners easy to remove, secure, and reconfigure for cargo use
- Molded all-weather liners have a thicker, more utilitarian look than carpet-style mats
Verdict: The best all-weather floor mats for drivers who need heavy-duty, waterproof protection against mud, snow, salt, and liquid spills.
4. 3D MAXpider Kagu All-Weather Floor Liners for Subaru Forester 2009–2013 (Full Set)
Best Heavy-Duty Floor Mats
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific |
|---|---|
| Material Type | all-weather |
| Auto Part Position | Rear |
| Included Components | Floor Mat |
These 3D MAXpider Kagu liners are molded to match the 2009–2013 Subaru Forester floorplan and provide heavy-duty all-weather protection. They use a multilayer TPR construction with raised edges and channel grooves to trap water, snow, mud, and road grime, and a textured bottom plus Velcro-style anchors to keep the mats from shifting. Installation is straightforward since the pieces are laser-scanned to the vehicle shape and align with factory clip locations. In daily use they are easy to clean—rinse or wipe off—and the material is claimed odorless and resistant to scratching. For buyers focused on durability, the thicker Kagu design absorbs vibrations and stands up to frequent heavy soiling better than thin carpet mats. Limitations: they add visible, utilitarian styling compared with OEM carpet and take up more space around pedals, so check pedal clearance during fitment and expect a stiffer feel underfoot compared with soft liners.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize rugged, long-lasting interior protection and want liners that tolerate heavy, repeated soiling without frequent replacement.
Less Ideal for: Drivers seeking plush, carpet-like appearance or the softest underfoot comfort should consider carpeted or premium textile mats instead.
- Vehicle-specific laser-scanned fit for close coverage and alignment with factory clip positions
- Raised edges and channel grooves trap liquids and debris to protect carpet
- Durable TPR multilayer construction resists heavy soiling and abrasion
- Anti-slip bottom layer with Velcro-style anchors minimizes mat movement
- Easy to clean: rinse or wipe dry for quick maintenance
- Stiffer, utilitarian look and feel compared with carpeted floor mats
Verdict: The best heavy-duty floor mats for users who want thick, reinforced construction that stands up to frequent heavy soiling and hard wear.
5. CARTIST Custom-Fit Floor Mats and Cargo Liner for Subaru Forester 2009–2013
Best Custom-Fit Floor Mats
| Compatible with Vehicle Type | Passenger Car |
|---|---|
| Fit Type | Vehicle Specific Fit |
| Material Type | Rubber (TPE) |
These CARTIST mats are a tailored floor and cargo liner set made specifically for the 2009–2013 Subaru Forester. Molded with 3D screening to follow the vehicle's curves, the set includes front, rear, and cargo pieces plus a backrest mat so coverage reaches corners and crevices without trimming. Constructed from high-density TPE, the liners are waterproof, flexible in hot and cold conditions, and resist cracking or hardening over time. Raised grooves and anti-slip textures trap water, mud, and snow and make cleanup as simple as a rinse. The textured backing and integrated anti-slip features help the mats stay in place while allowing pedal movement. Expect a near-factory look and solid coverage, though buyers wanting carpet-style luxury or heavier, rubberized ballast might prefer different materials. Installation is straightforward for a vehicle-specific set, and maintenance is low effort for regular all-weather use.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize precise, vehicle-specific coverage and easy all-weather protection for a 2009–2013 Forester and want mats that stay put and clean up quickly.
Less Ideal for: Shoppers seeking plush carpet-style floor liners or a heavier, weighty rubber mat for a more premium cabin feel should consider other options.
- Custom 3D-molded fit that follows Forester floor contours for edge-to-edge coverage
- Made from high-density TPE that is waterproof, temperature resistant, and odorless
- Raised grooves and channels trap water, snow, and debris for easy cleaning
- Anti-slip backing and textured surfaces help keep mats in place while allowing pedal movement
- Material is molded TPE so it provides a utilitarian look rather than carpet-like luxury
Verdict: The best custom-fit floor mats for shoppers who need precise coverage, secure attachment to floor anchors, and a near-factory fitted appearance.
Choosing the Right 2009-2013 Subaru Forester Floor Mats: Key Factors to Consider
Fit and Coverage
Fit is the single most important factor for the Forester because tailored mats reduce movement, prevent debris from reaching carpeting, and ensure coverage of high-wear zones like driver heel areas. Properly shaped floor liners follow the contours of foot wells and the transmission hump so they do not bunch up or leave gaps where dirt can accumulate.
Coverage also matters in the cargo area if you frequently carry wet gear or pets. Full-coverage liners with raised lips help trap liquids and mud, while mats that leave the sides exposed will let moisture run down into carpeting. For owners who prioritize tidy interiors, choosing mats that map closely to the Forester's footwell geometry will deliver the best protection and appearance over time.
Material and Durability
Materials range from heavy rubber to thermoplastic elastomers and carpet-faced options. For a Forester that sees outdoor activity or winter driving, denser rubber or TPE compounds resist cracking in cold weather and stand up to repeated cleaning. Softer carpet mats look nicer but can absorb stains and retain moisture unless backed by a waterproof layer.
Assess the expected lifespan relative to your use. Mats with reinforced heel areas and thicker material at high-wear spots will last longer under frequent entry and exit. Also consider UV resistance if the vehicle spends a lot of time parked in sun, as inferior materials can discolor or become brittle.
Weatherproofing and Liquid Management
Subaru Forester owners often contend with snow, rain, and muddy trails, so liquid containment is critical. Look for raised edges or channels that guide water away from contact points and prevent spills from spreading to the carpet. Deep grooves and reservoirs can trap slush and salt, keeping it contained until you can remove and clean the mat.
Mats designed with integrated channels reduce the risk of slipperiness underfoot by moving liquids away from the pedals. If you live in a heavy-snow region, prioritize liners with robust ridges and a spill containment lip to avoid seepage during melting cycles.
Retention and Non-Slip Performance
Even well-fitting mats must stay in place. Check for retention systems that align with the Forester's factory anchor points or textured backing that minimizes movement. Mats that slide can create safety issues by interfering with pedal operation or by folding underfoot.
Non-slip surfaces on the top side help maintain traction for shoes, especially when wet. For driver safety, a secure connection to the floor and a heel pad that prevents premature wear are important. Consider mats with anti-skid nubs on the underside or compatible anchor slots that lock the mat into position.
Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance
Regular cleaning is a reality for an active Forester owner, so pick mats that you can remove, rinse, and dry quickly. Rubber and TPE liners typically hose off and dry fast, while carpeted mats may require vacuuming and spot treatment. Fast-drying materials reduce the risk of mold or odor after exposure to slush or spills.
Evaluate features like removable inserts, smooth drain channels, and whether the mat shape allows for easy removal without snagging on trim. Mats that can be cleaned in place or that stack compactly for storage will save time during seasonal swaps.
Comfort and Interior Aesthetics
While protection is primary, comfort and appearance also influence the ownership experience. Low-profile mats that match the vehicle's interior style may be preferable if you want a factory look. Conversely, thick heavy-duty liners provide better insulation and noise dampening but can feel bulky.
Consider how a mat's surface texture affects footwear grip and comfort during long drives. Some materials provide a warmer foot surface in winter and a less slippery surface in wet conditions. Balance how the mat looks with how it performs in your usual driving environment.
Cargo and Trunk Liner Options
Cargo liners protect the rear cargo area from spilled liquids, muddy equipment, and pet hair. For the 2009-2013 Forester, a dedicated cargo and trunk mat that matches the cargo floor contours will prevent items from sliding and reduce the chance of stains or odor transfer into the fabric beneath.
Choose liners with raised edges and a textured surface to keep loads stable. If you haul gardening supplies, sports gear, or pets frequently, a thick, wipeable liner will simplify cleanup and protect the factory cargo floor from abrasion and moisture.
- Raised lip contains liquids and debris
- Textured surfaces reduce cargo slippage
- Removable pieces make cleaning and storage easier
Best Mats for Winter Driving
Winter conditions demand mats that can handle salt, slush, and frequent hosing. Heavy-duty rubber or TPE liners with deep channels provide containment for melted snow and reduce salt contact with the carpet. Reinforced edges help avoid warping or cracking in subzero temperatures.
Also consider quick-dry materials to minimize odor and mildew. Mats that resist salt corrosion and are easy to rinse will extend the life of both the mat and the vehicle interior.
- Deep grooves trap slush and salt
- Cold-resistant materials prevent cracking
- Easy-to-rinse surfaces speed winter maintenance
Installation, Removal, and Seasonal Swaps
Simple installation and removal encourage routine cleaning. Look for mats that align with factory anchor points and that can be removed without struggling against door sills or trim. Lightweight but durable liners make seasonal swaps practical, especially if you switch between carpeted and all-weather options.
Labeling or a clear orientation shape helps ensure correct placement after cleaning. If you plan to switch mats seasonally, keep an extra set that is stored flat to avoid permanent deformation.
- Anchor-compatible mats reduce installation time
- Lightweight liners ease seasonal swapping
- Keep spare set flat to prevent warping
Cleaning and Care Practices
Routine maintenance prolongs mat life and keeps the Forester interior fresh. For rubber and TPE liners, a hose and mild detergent usually suffice; allow mats to dry completely before reinstalling. Carpeted mats benefit from regular vacuuming and periodic spot cleaning for stains.
Address salt and acidic spills quickly to prevent long-term damage to both mats and carpet. Inspect backing and anchor points during each cleaning to ensure retention features remain functional.
- Rinse and air-dry rubber liners thoroughly
- Vacuum and treat stains on carpeted mats promptly
- Check anchors and backing for wear during cleaning
Custom Fit Versus Universal Liners
Custom fit floor mats are molded to the Forester's footwells and usually offer superior coverage and retention. Universal car mats can be more affordable and flexible but often require trimming and may leave gaps that collect dirt and moisture.
If exact fit and full protection are priorities, choose a custom-molded liner. If you prefer a temporary or budget solution, make sure universal options can be securely anchored and cover critical wear areas.
- Custom fit: best coverage and retention
- Universal: flexible but may require trimming
- Consider intended use before choosing
Still looking for the perfect fit?
Select your Subaru Forester configuration to see the most relevant Floor Mats recommendations
How We Chose the Best 2009-2013 Subaru Forester Floor Mats
We focused on attributes that matter specifically for a 2009-2013 Subaru Forester interior and typical owner needs. Core evaluation criteria included fit and coverage, material durability, weatherproofing and liquid management, ease of cleaning, and long-term retention features such as anchor compatibility. We also considered ride comfort and tread patterns for slip resistance, especially for drivers who frequently load gear or encounter wet and snowy conditions.Products were required to offer clear compatibility with the 2009-2013 Forester and to provide either a vehicle-specific mold or a demonstrably better coverage profile than universal alternatives. We excluded one-size-fits-all mats that lack sufficient heel pad reinforcement or that do not anchor securely in place. Technical factors weighted more heavily than aesthetics: precise coverage of foot wells and cargo area, raised edges for liquid containment, and materials that resist cracking in cold climates were prioritized.We did not include options that focused solely on appearance without addressing retention or water containment. The goal was to surface practical, durable floor mat choices that handle everyday use and seasonal extremes for the Forester.
Our full evaluation process is outlined in our review methodology.
FAQ
How do I know if a mat will anchor correctly in my Forester?
Look for mats that state compatibility with the 2009-2013 Forester and that include anchor slots or clips matching factory points. If a mat lacks clear anchor compatibility, examine whether its underside has non-slip textures or removable fasteners to secure it in place.
Can I use universal car mats in the Forester safely?
You can use universal mats, but they often require trimming and may not align with anchor points. Ensure they do not shift under the pedals and consider adding aftermarket non-slip backing or using purpose-made retention clips to improve safety.
What is the best way to clean rubber liners after winter?
Rinse off loose salt and debris with a hose, scrub stubborn spots with a mild detergent, then rinse thoroughly and allow the mats to air dry completely before reinstalling. This prevents salt accumulation and reduces the chance of odors or corrosion to the underlying carpet.
Are carpeted mats a bad choice for Forester owners who hike and camp often?
Carpeted mats can trap moisture and odors when used for dirty outdoor activities. If you frequently bring muddy gear or wet boots into the vehicle, all-weather liners or heavy-duty mats that wipe clean are generally more practical.
Do floor mats affect pedal feel or clearance in the Forester?
Ill-fitting or unsecured mats can interfere with pedal travel if they shift or bunch up near the pedals. Choose floor mats with proper retention, and always verify pedal clearance after installation to ensure safe operation.
How long should quality Forester floor mats last with regular use?
Longevity depends on material and use. Heavy-duty rubber or TPE liners can last many years with proper care, while carpeted mats may show wear sooner in high-traffic areas. Regular cleaning and avoiding prolonged exposure to harsh chemicals will extend service life.
Final Verdict
When choosing floor mats for your 2009-2013 Subaru Forester, prioritize fit and containment first, then match material to your typical use. If you face snow and mud frequently, heavy-duty all-weather liners with raised edges and secure anchors will protect the interior and simplify maintenance. For owners who prefer a refined cabin look and lighter use, low-profile or carpet-faced mats can be suitable if they offer adequate backing and retention.Balance tradeoffs between comfort, durability, and ease of cleaning to find the best option for your driving habits. Focusing on coverage, retention, and weather resistance will help you pick a mat that keeps your Forester clean and functional for years to come.
Explore More:
- Check out all Subaru Forester parts & accessories
- Explore Interior Accessories
- Browse all Accessories
